John C. Mitby

John C. Mitby: Experienced Legal Counsel for Complex Business Matters

John C. Mitby is a highly respected and accomplished attorney offering comprehensive legal counsel to a diverse range of clients, including businesses, engineering firms, insurance companies, financial institutions, and healthcare and elder care facilities. With a distinguished career spanning decades, Mr. Mitby possesses a proven track record of resolving complex legal disputes and providing strategic guidance across a multitude of business and litigation matters. His expertise encompasses commercial litigation, mediation, arbitration, and a deep understanding of real estate, financing, and business transactions.

Since January 1, 2015, Mr. Mitby has served as a senior partner at Hurley, Burish & Stanton, S.C., leveraging his extensive experience and leadership to guide the firm and its clients. Prior to this role, he was managing partner at Axley Brynelson, LLP from 2009 to 2014, demonstrating his commitment to strategic leadership and client service.

Mr. Mitby’s practice is built on a foundation of meticulous attention to detail and a strategic approach to problem-solving. He excels at navigating intricate legal challenges and consistently delivers favorable outcomes for his clients. He is frequently sought after for his expertise when complex legal issues arise, and his ability to act as an expert witness further solidifies his standing in the legal community.

Key Areas of Practice:

• Commercial Litigation: Mr. Mitby specializes in resolving disputes related to contracts, real estate, employment, financing, and insurance matters. His litigation experience extends to a wide variety of complex business disputes, providing clients with robust defense and strategic counsel.
• Mediation & Arbitration: Recognized for his exceptional mediation and arbitration skills, Mr. Mitby offers effective and efficient dispute resolution services, minimizing litigation costs and maximizing client satisfaction.
• Real Estate Transactions: Mr. Mitby provides expert legal guidance on a broad spectrum of real estate transactions, including acquisitions, sales, and complex property matters.
• Business & Corporate Law: He advises businesses on legal matters related to formation, governance, contracts, intellectual property, and other critical business operations.
• Insurance Coverage Litigation: Mr. Mitby's experience in insurance coverage issues provides his clients with astute strategic advice and effective representation.

Significant Transactions & Litigation Experience:

• Complex Business Acquisitions: Mr. Mitby has advised on numerous acquisitions, including those involving professional and technical businesses, consistently ensuring favorable terms and protecting client interests.
• Large-Scale Transactions: He played a key role in several high-profile transactions, such as the reorganization of a cooperative, the sale of America’s largest water park, the sale of a bank, and the sale of the House on the Rock – a testament to his ability to handle complex and high-stakes deals.
• Contract Disputes & Litigation: Mr. Mitby has a strong record of success in defending clients against contract disputes, providing strategic counsel and aggressive representation in court.
• Insurance Coverage Disputes: He has effectively navigated complex insurance coverage issues, securing favorable outcomes for his clients in a variety of circumstances.

Credentials & Recognition:

• AV Preeminent® Peer Review Rated: Consistently recognized by Martindale-Hubbell® for his outstanding legal abilities and ethical standards (10/10).
• Super Lawyers® Recognition: Recognized as a Top 25 Super Lawyer Attorney.
• ABOTA President: Formerly President of the American Board of Trial Advocates (ABOTA).
• State Bar Leadership: Chairperson of the Litigation Section of the State Bar.
• Pro Bono Service: Extensive recognition for numerous pro bono projects through the Dane County and State Bar.
• Madison Soccer Hall of Fame: Elected to the Madison Soccer Hall of Fame for his significant contributions to the development of Reddan Soccer Park.
• Van Wie & Olson Foundations: President of the Van Wie and Olson Foundations.
• Legal Expertise: Admitted to practice in Wisconsin state and federal courts, Colorado, and the United States Supreme Court.

Awards & Accolades: Throughout his career, Mr. Mitby has been repeatedly recognized for his exceptional legal expertise and service. He has been named “Lawyer of the Year” for Litigation – Municipal, Litigation – Construction, and Litigation – Municipal by Madison (2019, 2014, 2013 respectively), and recognized as Best Lawyers© 2015 Litigation – Municipal “Lawyer of the Year” in Madison, and 2016 Best Lawyers in America, Lawyer of the Year, Litigation - Construction, Madison (2016). He has also been named one of Madison’s top Alternative Dispute Resolution Mediation attorneys by Madison Magazine and has been listed in “Ten Who Made a Difference,” 2004, and “Know Your Madisonian,” 1988. He is listed in Best Attorney USA since 1993.

Mr. Mitby is dedicated to providing his clients with the highest level of legal representation and service. His extensive experience, strategic thinking, and commitment to achieving favorable outcomes make him an invaluable asset to any legal matter.