Gerry P. Fagan

Gerry P. Fagan: Montana’s Trusted Litigation Attorney

Gerry P. Fagan is a seasoned civil litigator and a dedicated Montana native, providing exceptional legal counsel since 1998. Recognized as a leading attorney within the state, Gerry’s firm specializes in aggressive, yet pragmatic, defense strategies across a broad range of complex litigation matters. With over two decades of experience, he has cultivated a reputation for meticulous preparation, strategic thinking, and a deep understanding of Montana’s legal landscape. Gerry’s commitment to his clients’ success is unwavering, and he consistently delivers results – whether it’s securing a favorable settlement or achieving victory in court.

Gerry’s practice is built on a foundation of expertise in defending individuals and businesses against significant claims. He has earned numerous accolades, including being named Lawyer of the Year: Litigation – Insurance by the Billings Chamber of Commerce on multiple occasions (2026, 2023, 2019, 2016), and Lawyer of the Year: Personal Injury Litigation – Defendants (2022), demonstrating his superior skills and dedication.

His primary focus lies in defending clients against a diverse portfolio of legal challenges, including personal injury, product liability, malpractice, employment disputes, and municipal liability claims. Gerry’s experience extends to complex commercial litigation, insurance coverage disputes, and construction disputes – often representing some of the largest contractors in the Billings area. He possesses a particular talent for handling intricate legal arguments and navigating challenging legal precedents.

Gerry’s track record speaks for itself. He has successfully tried over ten jury trial cases throughout Montana, including significant cases in Billings, Missoula, and Great Falls. Notably, he has successfully defended manufacturers of automobiles, motorcycles, and trenching machines, protecting their reputations and minimizing financial exposure. His expertise also encompasses defending oral surgeons on a statewide basis and representing employers against wrongful discharge suits, safeguarding their rights and interests. Gerry has a profound understanding of municipal law, having successfully defended numerous cities and towns in Montana against a wide array of claims, including those alleging wrongful death by law enforcement officers – a testament to his commitment to justice and protecting the public interest.

Beyond his courtroom successes, Gerry is recognized for his strategic approach to insurance coverage issues. He has achieved significant victories in insurance coverage declaratory judgment actions, including one instance where he secured an Order reimbursing an insurer over $350,000 in defense fees expended – a remarkable demonstration of his ability to advocate effectively on behalf of his clients.

Gerry’s approach to litigation is grounded in a deep respect for the law and a genuine concern for his clients. He understands the emotional and financial pressures associated with legal disputes and is dedicated to providing compassionate and personalized service. He leverages his extensive experience and knowledge to build strong defense strategies and strives to achieve the most favorable outcomes for his clients.

Practice Areas

• Litigation - Insurance
• Commercial Litigation
• Government Contracts
• Insurance Law
• Litigation - Health Care
• Litigation - Municipal
• Medical Malpractice Law - Defendants
• Municipal Law
• Personal Injury Litigation - Defendants
• Litigation - ERISA
• Litigation - Labor and Employment
• Product Liability Litigation - Defendants
• Government Relations Practice

Education & Credentials

Gerry graduated with Honors from the University of Montana School of Law and has been practicing civil litigation in Montana since 1998. He has been admitted to the Montana Bar and holds numerous awards recognizing his excellence in the legal profession. His dedication to upholding the highest standards of legal practice has earned him the respect of his peers and the trust of his clients. He continuously seeks to expand his knowledge and skills to provide his clients with the most up-to-date legal strategies.

Awards

• Lawyer of the Year: Litigation – Insurance, Billings (2026)
• Lawyer of the Year: Litigation – Insurance, Billings (2023)
• Lawyer of the Year: Personal Injury Litigation – Defendants, Billings (2022)
• Lawyer of the Year: Litigation – Insurance, Billings (2019)
• Lawyer of the Year: Insurance Law, Billings (2016)

Recognitions

• Recognized in Best Attorney USA since 2013
• Recognized: Commercial Litigation
• Recognized: Government Contracts
• Recognized: Insurance Law
• Recognized: Litigation - Health Care
• Recognized: Litigation - Insurance
• Recognized: Litigation - Municipal
• Recognized: Medical Malpractice Law - Defendants
• Recognized: Municipal Law
• Recognized: Personal Injury Litigation - Defendants

Contact Gerry P. Fagan today to discuss your legal needs and explore how his experience and dedication can protect your rights and interests.