Andrew Agati

Andrew Agati: Leading Insurance Recovery and High-Stakes Defense Attorney

Andrew Agati is a highly accomplished and results-oriented attorney specializing in complex insurance recovery and high-stakes defense matters. With a distinguished career spanning over 15 years, he has established a formidable reputation for aggressively pursuing insurance claims and fiercely defending corporate clients against significant allegations. Andrew’s expertise encompasses a remarkably broad range of industries and legal disciplines, consistently delivering exceptional outcomes for his clients.

Initially recognized for his prowess in guiding corporate clients through intricate and sensitive legal challenges, Andrew has evolved into a leading expert in insurance recovery. He consistently secures substantial compensation for policyholders across diverse sectors, including financial institutions, technology companies, and general commercial entities. His strategic approach and deep understanding of insurance policies – encompassing E&O, financial institution bonds, cyber policies, EPL, D&O, product recall, CGL, property, builder’s risk, and more – have resulted in nearly $420 million in recoveries.

However, Andrew's skillset extends far beyond insurance recoveries. He is frequently called upon to defend major corporations facing some of the most challenging and high-stakes legal disputes imaginable. This includes representing publicly traded companies in critical defense actions, such as defending against False Claims Act lawsuits, navigating complex regulatory investigations, and mitigating significant investor losses in instances like Ponzi schemes. His ability to handle these multifaceted matters demonstrates a strategic mind, meticulous attention to detail, and a relentless commitment to protecting his clients’ interests.

Andrew’s experience isn't limited to the courtroom. He has a proven track record of success in appellate proceedings, having served as lead appellate counsel in a notable defense against a class certification denial. This highlights his strategic thinking, legal acumen, and commitment to achieving favorable outcomes at every stage of the legal process.

Practice Areas

Andrew Agati’s practice areas reflect his comprehensive expertise and diverse experience:

• Commercial Litigation: He expertly handles a wide array of complex commercial disputes, leveraging his deep understanding of legal principles and strategic thinking to achieve favorable results for his clients.
• Insurance Law: A core focus of his practice, Andrew specializes in navigating the intricacies of insurance policies and maximizing recovery for corporate policyholders.
• Mass Tort Litigation / Class Actions – Defendants: He provides robust defense counsel in mass tort and class action lawsuits, employing sophisticated legal strategies to protect his clients' rights.
• Construction Law
• Financial Services Regulation Law
• Product Liability Litigation
• Product Liability Litigation – Defendants
• Litigation – Insurance
• Title Insurance and Reinsurance Treaties
• Excess and Umbrella Policies

Awards & Recognition

• Lawyer of the Year: Mass Tort Litigation / Class Actions – Defendants, Cleveland (2025)
• Recognized: Commercial Litigation
• Recognized: Insurance Law
• Recognized: Mass Tort Litigation / Class Actions – Defendants
• Practice Area: Construction Law
• Practice Area: Financial Services Regulation Law
• Practice Area: Litigation - Insurance
• Practice Area: Product Liability Litigation
• The Best Lawyers in America®, Commercial Litigation, 2019-24
• Insurance Law, 2024
• Mass Tort Litigation / Class Actions – Defendants, 2024
• AV Preeminent®, Martindale-Hubbell

Education & Credentials

Andrew Agati is a dedicated and experienced attorney committed to providing exceptional legal services to his clients. His focus on delivering superior results, combined with his deep knowledge of the legal landscape, makes him a trusted advisor and strategic partner.

Affiliations

• Recognized Since: Recognized in Best Attorney USA since 2019

Contact Information

City: Cleveland
State: Ohio
Country: United States